By Matthew Coller
Happy Friday, everyone! What a time to be alive. Let’s dive into your questions…
Clark…. I hear everyone talking about Flores becoming a head coach based on the excellent defenses that he has created the last three years.
I totally agree that Flores has tapped into a new philosophy of keeping offenses off balance, but it seems to me that his strategy has become more effective due to the players that he has grown into the unit they are due their experience and intelligence.
I am not sure how transportable that philosophy is without the players he has in MN.
AVG, Harrison, Cashman, Murphy, Turner, etc allow the defense to react in real time to shifts in the offense. Even the defensive line needs to understand their role and drop into middle coverage on some plays.
If Flores was a head coach, do you think he could have time to create this level of defense somewhere else with different players?
Well, there’s a lot of layers there. I’ve always been a believer in “it’s the players, not the plays” but when Flores has essentially hand picked the players over the last three years to build a group of guys that can handle his scheme and take total ownership of it, he deserves a lot of credit for that as well. He’s rigging the deck by putting together this group and developing guys like LDR, Redmond, Jackson etc. and believing in free agents like Wilson and Rodgers who weren’t full-time starters before.
The fact that he’s already been a head coach before also plays into it. As messy as it was, the Dolphins were tanking joke before he got there and they ended up with winning records.
It’s going to be really, really, really hard to repeat what he’s done with this group in 2026 because this is a once-per-decade type defense. But if the question is whether he could be a head coach somewhere and build a defense that is dominant, I’d say the answer is yes as long as he is able to pick the types of players that fit with how he plays. We saw in 2023 and 2024 when they were cobbling some stuff together and in 2025 when he had DTs who didn’t fit that it wasn’t the same as it is this year, even if it was still above average.
The biggest question about Flores as a head coach isn’t going to be about the defensive side though. It’s going to be whether he can be a delegator and build a relationship with his quarterback because all the reports from his time in Miami suggest those were issues.
Brad L…. When players are developed (ie Redmond) who is responsible more the coordinator or the position coach?
The player is the most responsible for their development by 57 miles over the next thing. Jalen Redmond and Levi Drake Rodriguez are smart, super driven and they understood what it was going to take in order for them to make it. They’ve got that dog in them, more or less.
After that, position coaches are important for building relationships with those guys and emphsizing certain things in order to help them develop the best they can. You see this with Keenan McCardell. He has a really great understanding of how to teach the position from a technical standpoint and then is a positive driving force behind those guys believing in themselves.
Then the coordinator has to put them in position to succeed. I’m not sure that every player on the Vikings defense would be this version of themselves in a different system. If Redmond had a different job, he’d probably still be good but everyone is given the best chance to succeed here. He’s getting a lot of one-on-one matchups because of the five-man fronts and blitzes and he can win those. If he had to take on double teams for 60 minutes, it might be different.
A lot of things have to come together for late-round picks and UDFAs to work out. Sometimes it all just clicks.
Hunter S… How far does Brett Thorson punt the ball in the high altitude this week?
How long of a field goal is KOC going to be comfortable going for after considering a long miss puts the 49ers close to field goal range?
I think if Thorson really let loose — like from his own 10-yard line — he could probably boot the ball 75 yards. He has a massive leg, pretty close to what Ryan Wright could do. The question is whether you actually want to kick it 75 yards. Probably not because that’s going to give the returner a ton of space to find lanes. Maybe instead we’ll see the altitude used for kicking it higher in the air and getting better hang time.
For field goals, you probably want to stick to like 55-60 yards. Anything else would be free points for the opponent. There’s even an argument that field goal kickers being so much better these days has actually made coaches worse decision makers in terms of going for fourth downs because they know they can make it.
I would love to see a 70-yard attempt at the end of the half though.
Brad L… The defense is outstanding but each of the players is human. Odds are they are bound to have a clunker (relatively speaking). Which game do you suspect is most likely for that to happen? Or have we already seen it?
The closest they’ve come this year was the Lions game and we all understand how that happened in the second half (and they kept them to 19 points).
If there’s going to be a clunker, it would make the most sense for it to either be this week, next time against the Lions or in Week 18 against the Bears. It’s really hard to see Atlanta, Carolina, Washington or New York being able to roll against them.
If it was one of the random teams, I’d probably go with Atlanta because they’ll be coming back from such an insane stretch that they’ve gotta be worn down to some extent and the Falcons have amazing weapons. You can easily give up 200 yards to Bijan Robinson if he breaks into the open a couple times.
That’s really what makes this defense different though. They are so overwhelming to opposing QBs that it’s hard to see how any team would get on a roll against them and keep it going for an entire game. We’ve seen individual big plays but we’ve never seen a four-quarter game and that even goes back to midway through last year.
Jason… That was nice of Kirk to scout the 9ers before the Vikings play them. What needs to happen to have him avoid a similarly poor outing this time?
Pressure, pressure, pressure.
In that game, Cousins was 19-for-22 passing with a clean pocket and 3-for-10 with three INTs when he was under pressure. He has to get the ball out of his hands quickly and they have to block up against Nick Bosa, DeForest Buckner etc.
The 49ers haven’t graded well or produced well in terms of pass rush but part of that is opposing QBs not trying to go deep against them. They are No. 3 in the NFL in the lowest yards per completion allowed. A couple of Kirk’s picks were trying to push downfield so I’m thinking this needs to be a dink-and-dunk game for him to stay on point.
Jim L… Hi Matt, there has been a lot of discussion this week about the Vikings’ approach to preparing for the high altitude compared to the 49ers’ approach. What is your opinion? I hope the Vikings defense is not fatigued in the second half.
My opinion is that I have no freaking clue what the right approach actually is. The Vikings’ training staff is as scientific as it comes when we’re talking about stuff like this and it sounds like they’ve put a ton of thought into it. That’s the best you can really do. I’m sure whichever team loses will be criticized for having the wrong approach but I don’t know if uprooting a team for an entire week is better.
Brent K…. Hi Matthew, KOC made improving the QB room a main off-season objective after last season’s debacle at QB. I can’t figure out why KOC thought Kyler would be a better signing than bringing back Cousins. What are your thoughts on that? What have you heard?
Also, have you ever seen or heard anything from the Vikings that would support or refute the recent report from John Middlekauff that KOC “hated” McCarthy and pushed to trade him? It would make sense circumstantially, but could also be spin from the McCarthy camp.
You have to remember that Kyler cost $1.3 million. The difference between him and Kirk might have been keeping someone like Eric Wilson or adding Jauan Jennings (which seemed big at the time and might still be). Do we know that Kirk wanted to come back here this offseason? It’s not Madden where you can just sign whoever you want.
Also, did you know that Kirk was going to be fully recovered and play like he did this yar with the Raiders? I didn’t. I don’t think the Raiders even did. In Atlanta, he was struggling to drive the ball and looked so immobile that you were worried about him in the pocket. That really changed this year as he got farther away from the injury.
At the time, Kyler looked like the much better signing so long as KOC worked the offense around him. Turns out that he didn’t. Also turns out that Kyler got hurt. I’m not sure they would have done it if Kyler had stayed healthy because they might have won the Buffalo game with him.
In terms of KOC “hating” McCarthy, nobody really knows what was done/said behind the scenes. What we can say is that a quarterback who was that raw and unprepared for the pressure of the 2025 Vikings situation was not a good fit to be starting with a coach whose offense demands a ton from the quarterback. KOC would rightfully be frustrated and disappointed by McCarthy and maybe at times baffled by the way he handled certain things and not “hate” him.
Brad L… How many wins will it take to win the North? How do we get to that number?
Getting to 13 would be ideal but if you look at every team’s schedule, Chicago and Detroit have a lot of tough games coming up and I’m not sure they’re just going to run the table. I think if the Vikings reach 13, that can get the job done. Tie breakers might end up coming into play, which (right now) hurts them against Detroit and helps them against Chicago but we’ll see what happens in those last two NFCN games.
Roger N… Rob Brzezinski’s decision not to extend Jonathan Greenard and to trade him to Philadelphia for 2 3rd round picks has turned out to be the move that set the Vikings up for a potentially great season. Opening the door for Dallas Turner to shine and subsequently allowing Teasley to trade one of the Vikings’ 3rd round picks next year for Cousins when Kyler couldn’t take the reins for various reasons.
Yeah, I was a little skeptical of trading Greenard because I thought that he was a really good player and their depth was lacking. Not only did that turn out to be exactly the right move as Turner has become a star but signing Kyle Van Noy has really made up the difference. He’s rotated in and been a very solid playmaker for them.
Had we known that Turner was going to ascend and become a star like this, then it would have been a no-brainer. I’m thinking that Brian Flores and KOC must have had a good sense for that being around the corner when they made that decision.
Yelnats… I want to discuss the offensive line. PFF ranks Darrisaw 40/72, Huber 22/76, Brandel 11/35, Fries 51/76 and O’Neill 31/72. Center was my big concern coming into the season, because Brandel was changing position from guard. He seems to be the strength of the line. Fries suffers against power rushes, just like Bradbury did. My premise is that OL ratings and performance suffered along with the putrid QB play over most of the year-to-date season. OL performance will improve the second half of the season with Kirk releasing the ball sooner. A top 12 offense with the #1 defense makes a Super Bowl win a high probability.
There are absolutely factors that impact O-line performance when it comes to the QB. How long they hang onto the ball, pocket movement, matchups, scheme… all that stuff. Personally I think putting your O-line in third-and-long situations constantly is the easiest way for them to look worse than they really are.
In this instance, however, I’m not sure that it’s going to get wildly better. The run scheme just hasn’t seemed to be a great fit with the guys, which is dragging some of those overall rankings down, and the pass pro has been pretty good overall. In team pass blocking, PFF has them at 11th best. Without Donovan Jackson, it’s hard to be much better than that.
Tim…. Watched a few 49ers games this season. They have an aggressive defense with a disturbing tendency to lead with their helmets. Is their defensive coordinator responsible or is it position coaches? Or is this a bad take by me? Are you traveling to Mexico City Matthew?
The 49ers, always and forever, are going to be crazy aggressive. When I was watching their game against the Seahawks earlier this year, I thought that it was like a heavyweight fight between those two teams throwing the hardest punches they could at each other. John Lynch didn’t build a team of soft guys, that’s for sure. But I’m not sure that they intentionally try to lead with their helmets. Not saying you’re wrong, I just think it’s more of a play style by that team to be ultra physical.
I’m not going to Mexico City. It’s better for the podcast to be able to go live right after the game and not have to worry about how I’m going to get the show online. But I do have some FOMO for this one.
Lorne S… Hey Matt, with all the hoopla over Kirk coming back as our savior, what happens if he struggles over the next few games? What odds would you put on KOC going back to Kyler Murray, or do you think we’ve seen the last of Kyler in a Vikings uniform barring an injury to Kirk?
When Kyler is healthy, he’ll likely be the backup quarterback. I’m not sure how they could ever trust Wentz to go back in after what they saw on Monday Night Football. I can’t see any scenario where Kyler would go into the game unless Kirk got hurt though.
The way Kirk takes hits, there’s always a chance.
Axel P…. Hi Matthew. Thanks as always for your responses. The WR room has proved this year to be deep and competent. I don’t feel the same about the running backs, who are having a mediocre season overall and are one injury away from being basically non existent. Do you think that there’s still time to add a free agent RB who would make sense at this point?
Thank you for the question!
The time has probably passed to be able to add a free agent running back. It’s always possible to poach somebody off another team’s practice squad. That’s likely the only route that would be able to get them a workable player.
It’s a small thing, but I was a little annoyed that they didn’t put Audric Estime on the 53-man roster. He had 15 runs for 72 yards two weeks ago for the Saints. I felt like he was actually a guy who could go into a game.
To your point though, yes, they have a one-way ticket to Screwed Town if either of their running backs go down. Aaron Jones looked more spry last week — probably because he’s recovering from all that work at the beginning of the year — but it’s not sustainable to have him run 25 times per game. And we know that Jordan Mason isn’t really an all-around player and DeeJay Dallas is a blocker and special teamer. It’s very thin.
The lack of effort to add depth to that position is pretty confusing, to be honest.
Eric M… Why do the Vikings continue to run so many WR screens and not utilize the quick slant instead or in addition? Other than the one Jefferson key conversion Sunday, this seems to not be a very effective play. It’s frustrating to watch the same play not work time after time. It seems that a play where the receiver is moving forward at the catch, rather than standing still waiting for the ball, would produce more reliable YAC. I also think that guys like Price, Felton, and even Bartholomew give them options to get off the line quickly, besides just Jefferson. Or use the WRs to clear out the short coverage so Jones or Bartholomew could come out of the backfield.
They did use a quick slant to Jefferson for a first down last week that might have been an alert based on the corner playing off coverage. Part of it is probably that they get a lot of press coverage on Jefferson but Price, Jennings, Felton might all be guys who can hit on a quick slat vs. the right look.
The WR screens only bother me when Tai Felton or Jordan Addison are asked to block. That just doesn’t work because those guys weigh like 180 pounds.
I think it’s generally a good way to get the ball into Jefferson’s or Price’s hands but you’d like to see a little more cleverness added to the design if that’s how it’s going to work. Just lining up and having tiny dudes try to block it up kinda speaks a bit to our criticisms of KOC over the years. It’s probably a good play but the guy who’s being asked to do it can’t really do it.
Maybe this week’s screens were just part of knowing that Kirk had a limited menu and trying to make sure he was getting some completions.
Josh P… It seems like both teams will do a lot of rotations to minimize the affects of the altitude. There are the obvious position groups that run a lot that will need to rotate. I am not sure about the offensive lines. Where are the weak spots on both teams with regard to 2nd/3rd stringers playing more in this game.
The clearest positions are with wide receivers are defensive linemen. For the Vikings, being short Jordan Addison is definitely an issue in a game like this where the receivers might be doing a lot of running and they may need to give Justin Jefferson more plays off than they usually would. Getting Jauan Jennings back is good in that regard but we could see a lot of Gavin Bartholomew as an extra receiving weapon because they are still short a guy.
We don’t yet know if Mike Evans is playing. If he is, that’s a massive boost to the depth of the 49ers. They also traded for Keenan Allen at the deadline, which is a big help. They’ve got a couple other guys who can get in there if called upon like Jordan Watkins, who had a couple of catches for them last week vs. Dallas.
On the D-line, the emergence of Elijah Williams could matter a ton for the Vikings because that position has felt really thin all year with neither Caleb Banks or Domonique Orange really emeging yet as a super reliable rotational player. They can’t ask Jalen Redmond to play 65 plays in this game so it’s going to be needed.
For the 49ers, they have a couple of young rushers who work in. The guy to watch is Mykel Williams. He had a good game against the Cowboys. Rookie Romello Height had one great game this year and has otherwise been mediocre but they’ll need him. The loss of Gracen Halton, very good rookie, is a big injury because their backup DTs leave a lot to be desired.
I could also see Jake Golday and Ivan Pace Jr. getting used quite a bit in this one.
I’d say it’s an edge for the 49ers on offense and maybe slight edge for the Vikings on defense.
Pickle Enjoyer… I have a friend who is convinced that the Vikings could have signed Kirk and all the defensive free agents in 2024/2025. I know this is wrong but can you break it down for us why it was impossible? Thanks!
Your friend is right and wrong. Could they have kept Kirk and added Greenard, Cashman, Van Ginkel and Aaron Jones and kept other players around, sure. But they would have had to do unconscionable things to the salary cap with void years etc. in order to do that.
That would have caught up with them pretty quickly and they wouldn’t have the team that they do right now because they are jammed up against the cap currently. It worked out so much better this way.
As we’re playing the hindsight game with Cousins, does anyone remember what he looked like playing football in 2024? It was wildly better to have Sam Darnold that season because Cousins was nowhere near where he is now in terms of mobility and throwing the ball. He was floating pop flys and was struggling to even hand off on outside zone plays that year.
Walt K…. I saw our old friend Anthony Barr discuss on X the topic of open receivers with Orlovsky & Kurt Warner. He basically said that he saw open receivers during the game against the Bills (basically intimating that the QBs weren’t hitting their guys)which was in contrast to the other two guys’ opinions. Not sure if you know of the convo that I’m referring to, but in any case is that something that’s just considered subjective, or do coaches have set beliefs in what qualifies as open in any particular situation?
I saw their discussion. I thought all of them made valid points. The hard part about freezing the tape and saying whether wide receivers are open or not is that good quarterbacks tend to throw people open. You saw this last week. I’m not sure that either big-time throw that he made in the game was “open” when you froze the tape.
That said, I also watched the first half and didn’t think there was a lot of easy stuff out there for Wentz. I felt similarly about Kyler against the Lions. There was too much downfield stuff and I thought it was notable that Jefferson praised Kirk for throwing the ball underneath a lot and just executing plays.
I’m not entirely sure how coaches look at that because they know the plays and the reads so much better than us. KOC which “void” the QB was supposed to throw the ball into or when he was supposed to check it down. But let’s be honest, nobody should ever go 8-for-25.
The reality is, KOC needs a QB with mastery over the position. Kyler needs a coach who’s going to build it all around him like Drew Petzing did in Arizona.
ADGregory… Hey Mathew, isn’t it a mistake by Coaches to think players can thrive at an altitude of 7500 ft when they haven’t done so prior?
I truly have no clue. There’s a lotta football questions I feel confident answering but altitude questions are out of my depth. There’s really no other choice other than deferring to the team when it comes to their plan.
I’ve had people say that it’s a huge deal and I’ve had people say that it’s overstated. I wish I could give you a strong take. I got nothin.

